8/10/15 Begging the Question
- Brandon Bain
- Aug 11, 2015
- 3 min read
Updated: Nov 6, 2024
The Edvocate recently posted an article, School Security: Just Smoke and Mirrors?, that begs the question, “Does school security really increase safety?”
As the mother of a child killed at Sandy Hook and a national school safety advocate, I believe that whether it does or not, depends upon a few more considerations.
Hardware, technology, and programs alone cannot improve safety and security.
It’s more than installing cameras and door locks. These pieces of hardware and technology are examples of valuable security tools available today. Security is actually a practice that requires not only tools but also education, plans, procedures, and human involvement. As school security consultant Paul Timm, PSP teaches, “…products and systems play a complementary role to the real star of the show: people driven-solutions.” (School Security, How to Build and Strengthen a School Safety Program, 2015)
A locked front door combined with a buzz-in system can greatly restrict public access to vulnerable school occupants. But tools like this require a trained staff member on the other end to ensure that the door is securely locked, and to require identification and clearance of a visitor before granting access.
Just the same, cameras can serve as deterrents for negative behavior and even criminal activity in some communities, as Nancy La Vigne and her team found in a study with the Urban Institute. For many would-be perpetrators, a camera signals the risk of being caught or detected, either in the act or in preparation; and it’s enough to change their behavior. In a recent article in Scientific American, Sander Ban der Linden chronicles several scientific studies on the positive effect of merely perceived surveillance upon human behavior.
But cameras are undoubtedly more powerful with human involvement. A trained staff member to ensure the working order of cameras, monitor the live feed (or at least review it periodically), and report or address harmful or suspicious activity, can turn a camera into a tool of prevention rather than one of forensics.
<img decoding="async" class=" wp-image-2656 aligncenter lazyload" src="https://safeandsoundschools.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Blog-MicheleQuote-Option2-1024x357.png" alt="Blog-MicheleQuote-Option2" width="708" height="247" />
Programs, Staff Development, and Curricula can make all the difference.
Beyond hardware and technology is a wealth of tools in the form of safety programming, training, guidance, and curricula. These tools support school safety and security by developing a mindset for safety and preparedness in the school community.
Just as hardware and tools require support to be effective, so do programs and curricula. The best reporting and threat assessment protocols cannot address harmful actions or circumstances without adults trained to monitor, respond, and provide intervention. Just like the best anti-bullying, social-emotional learning, and emergency preparedness curricula carry little weight without support and reinforcement in the school community.
Below are several school safety programs and curricula to explore.
<img decoding="async" class=" wp-image-2662 aligncenter lazyload" src="https://safeandsoundschools.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/School-Safety-Resources-1024x850.png" alt="School Safety Resources" width="659" height="547" />
For truly safer schools, we have to ask tough questions like the ones The Edvocate poses in order to find a way to work together toward thoughtful answers and use the tools available to us wisely. Otherwise, school security and safety really is just smoke, mirrors, and very expensive window dressing.
To view the chart above with hyperlinks to each resource click this link: https://magic.piktochart.com/output/7223104-school-safety-resources. For more information and resources on school safety and security, visit safeandsoundschools.org.
–Michele Gay, Co-Founder/Executive Director, Safe and Sound Schools
Comments